The Countess & the Caveman: The Cercle Sadyana Murders

Never before have I so badly wanted to add something as gaudy as a jeweled dagger to my collection of seance paraphernalia, buuuuuut:

I can never predict the alluring mysteries that my research will uncover. During an archive search for spirit trumpet mediums, I uncovered what is likely the most fascinating accounts of spirit communication, murder, and paleoanthropology(?!) I have ever read. Because just how often do you stumble upon forgotten accounts of the rampaging spirit of a jealous Neanderthal in a French sanitarium killing 13 socially-elite seance enthusiasts? Well, just this once, apparently...

The Countess Marie Amelie Vernet-Lord was found murdered in November, 1928, "at her villa in Nice, with the hilt of a jeweled dagger sticking out of her breast." For some time, the Countess had been engaged in the seances of the Adyar Circle of Theosophy, also known as the "Cercle Sadyana," lead by "priestess of the occult" Mme. Arnelle. It was at one particular seance held on the grounds of the Domaine Les Courmettes sanitarium that the Countess felt a disturbing presence in the chamber. Mme. Arnelle offered to materialize the spirit, and, to their surprise:

"The mist...thickened into a shape. And it was no courtly gallant, no gentle giant. There stood a huge and hairy man, and ape-man with beetling brows, retreating forehead and a brutal head crowned with a bush of course hair. There was a malignant desire in its eyes, and as it stretched its long arms out to her, Arnelle wrenched her hands away from those of the Circle that held them. The Circle was broken and the figure blurred and vanished."

Countess Amelie Vernet-Lord

So it was that the mysterious spirit of a Neanderthal, which the Circle named "Ajax," began its unhealthy obsession with Countess Vernet-Lord. From that point onward, the prehistoric spirit became a thuggish nuisance in the Cercle Sadyana's sessions. The language barrier proved frustrating, and the ectoplasmic entity simply "waved his arms, thumped his chest, and made grimaces. Nobody could understand what he was trying to say, but clearly he wanted Amelie, and was always angry and threatening because she wouldn't understand what he was trying to tell her."

A Trio of Courmette's Prehistoric Structures...is that Ajax's old homestead to the left?

The presence of the Neanderthal's spirit was particularly appropriate given the locale; the Domaine Les Courmettes was a popular a sanitarium for the wealthy, and the land on which it is located is lousy with prehistoric middens, monoliths, and paleolithic shelters dating as far back as 50,000 years. So that ancient spirits of smitten Neanderthals wander the craggy hillsides comes of little wonder. And the sanatorium where these seances took place still stands, making it a must-visit for historians of Spiritualism.

The Sanatorium de Courmettes in 1920, as it would have appeared during the Cercle Sadyana's residency.

Ajax's spirit continued to disturb the group, even after the departure of the Countess to America upon her marriage to Horace Wilfred Lord. The arrangement didn't last long, however, and within months, the Countess had returned to Nice and her spiritualistic endeavors with the Cercle Sadyana, where Ajax's fervor and jealousy gained momentum.

Then the deaths began.

1920s Advertisement for the Courmette Sanatorium D'Heliotherapie.

Of the 15 people in attendance at the wedding of Countess Amelie to Horace Lord just a few months previously, only 2 would survive in a supposed spiritual rampage that would make believers of Tutankamen's curse sit up and take notice. It all happened in the course of weeks after Amelie's return. The presiding pastor dropped dead of a sudden heart attack. Alfred Vernet, the bride's cousin, was found dead in his porch chair, and his brother Edmund found dead under the exact same circumstances the very next day. Madame Louise Raegger, a member of the Cercle Sadyana, "died while laughing and chatting with visitors," while the maid of honor died in the middle of a public reception. There were many others, with the 13th victim being the Countess Amelie herself. The authorities arrested Count Wencelas de Klupfel for the Countess's murder. Not only was his jeweled dagger plunged into her chest, he confessed to the crime, though maintained: "There's no use asking me why I did it. I don't know. I remember nothing." 

The Cercle Sadyana had a different theory.

It was the belief among Countess Amelie's intimates that Count Klupfel had not murdered Amelie in cold blood. Rather, they surmised, the jealous spirit of Ajax, their "l'homme prehistorique," was to blame for the murders:

"The theory of the occultists is that "Ajax" was so angry at the marriage that he wiped out almost everybody concerned in it before he finally took possession of de Klupfel and used him to convert his too material sweetheart into another ghost."
 

The Forgiving Husband: Horace Wilfred Lord

The alibi is fascinating not only in its premise, but in the insistence by which the murdered Countess's intimates subscribed to the belief, including her own husband, Horace Wilfred Lord, who wrote to French authorities asking all charges to be dropped: "In the name of God, and in the memory of my dear wife, have pity on poor Wencelas de Klupfel." Indeed, de Klupfel invoked this as his defense, which the newspapers were quick to point out had not been used in the French courts since the Middle Ages. 

The defense, as one might expect, didn't work, and de Klupfel was found guilty for the Countess's murder.

The sanatorium still stands, and there is a beautiful picture gallery of the grounds some 5 years past located here. It is a locale I hope to one day explore. To wander the grounds where the Cercle Sadyana once assembled, and see the prehistoric middens they claimed Ajax once called home is just too alluring. By plane, train, or automobile, this is one destination at the top of my list.

The former sanatorium in 2007, currently closed but well-maintained.

Rogues Always Have Money: Florizel's "Itongu"

Last week's blog post reviewed Florizel von Reuter's use of the newly-rediscovered "Additor" and "Hesperus" talking board set the violinist detailed over the course of 3 books and multiple articles. As we've seen, Von Reuter was always quick to dismiss Ouija and planchettes in the pages of his works, but his distaste for another item he witnessed actually reveals yet another device not previously in the talking board record. It was found as I studied the pages of Florizel's 1928 book The Psychic Experiences of a Musician (in Search of Truth) at the Harry Ransom Center here in Austin.   

The new device is called the "Itongu," first introduced to Florizel and his mother in late March or early April, 1926, while they were in New York:

"A few days later a gentleman brought us an American writing-apparatus called "Itongu," which consisted of a flat heart-shaped piece of wood, which one placed on a board similar to the Additor but much larger. In order to simplify the task of writing, the inventor of this apparatus had obligingly prepared a series of printed words and answers to the questions. One table contained all the words pertaining to family relations such as mother, father, brother, sister, aunt, uncle, wife, husband, friend, even ''sweetheart'' was not forgotten. Another list of questions could be inserted at will, such phrases as: "You did right," "You did wrong," You will make a journey,'' '' You will receive a letter,'' ''I advise you to keep on as you are doing,'' etc."

Answer Overload! By the 1920s, many planchette manufacturers piggybacked on the
Ouija craze with printed sheets that allowed the planchette to act as an indicator, rather than
an automatic writer, resulting in an overload of printed replies.

It is a confusing description. The "flat heart-shaped piece of wood" and "writing apparatus" description immediately invokes the image of a classic American planchette, with the accompanying "printed words and answers" calling to mind the exhaustively wordy paper inserts to convert writing planchettes to pointing ouija-like indicators that were popular accessories included with planchettes of this period, including the Chad Valley "Futuroscope & Mystereone" sheets, the Glevum Games "Physio-Psychophone," and the Weyers Bros "Ouija-Planchette Combination" sheet. Except that we know it was a board, not a sheet, and "similar to the Additor" (which was 12-inches by 5-inches), "but much larger."

A Refresher: Detail of the Additor.

But there's an important distinction in Florizel's record, as well. The Additor, through descriptions and pictures, is positively a slide-plate device akin to W.T. Braham's "Wonderful/Telepathic Spirit Communicator" apparatus, patented in 1910 and still for sale by Two Worlds Publishing around the period Florizel's communications flourished. But despite the sliding operation of the indicator of this apparatus that is decidedly *not* actually writing, it is important for our review of the Itongu here to note that Florizel frequently and erroneously refers to the Additor itself as a "writing apparatus":

"...one immediately began to write..."  

 "Upon this second occasion the writing was much more fluent. Apparently he had mastered the technique of the apparatus."

"...the sentences it had written were aphorisms..." 

"...I deduced that the writer was not a German..."

"...inverted writing is being transmitted..."

Given his misleading term for the Additor's operation (forgivable, given that Florizel, as the transcriber, was doing an awful lot of actual writing to record the Additor's messages), it is safe to assume that the Itongu is not a writing planchette, and more akin to a slide-plate device, particularly with the following passage:

"Thus the entire contrivance did not rise above the level of a child's plaything. If one's finger-tips got the little wooden slab (that moved on a narrow wooden axis, being kindly provided with a groove to assist its motion) to move at all, one was sure to receive a message from one's mother (even if living), one's wife (even if one never had one), or one's sweetheart even, or anyone else under whose name the slab happened to stop."

An evolutionary selection of slide-plate devices

So, more clues. We now have a heart-shaped "slab" for an indicator that "moved on a narrow wooden axis, being kindly provided with a groove to assist its motion." Which immediately calls to mind the grooved rail of the aforementioned Braham's and Two Worlds' models. And, this all takes place on a board "similar to the Additor, but much larger." Which would nearly have to be a prerequisite, given the numerous printed answers on the boards face, including an exhaustive list of possible relatives and "another list that could be inserted at will," which makes it likely the device had multiple insert answer cards ("a series of printed words and answers") that one would change out depending on the topic of conversation.

Despite Florizel's distaste for the Itongu, which was rivaled only by his scorn for the Ouija, he had his mother take the device for a spin at his friend's insistence:

"My friend was anxious to have us test the Itongu in comparison to the Additor, so my mother placed the fingers of her left hand on the Additor, and those of her right hand on the Itongu, closed her eyes, and awaited results. The slab on the Itongu did not move, but almost immediately Euphrosyne [Grace von Reuter's primary spirit guide on the Additor] wrote on the Additor in inverted German, ordering us quite dictatorially to remove the' 'swindle-board'' from the table, as she absolutely refused to have anything to do with it."
Indeed, the Additor's controlling spirit was outright hostile toward the new arrival competing for her attention:

"Upon being asked to state her reasons for preferring the Additor, she replied: ''Herr Schwenke'' (the inventor's name) ''is an honest man''; and later: ''Bad luck goes with the swindle-board'' (which statement we afterwards discovered was true). My Italian friend also promptly made known his disapproval with the word: ''Rascals." Afterwards he wrote : ''I birbanti hanno sempre denaro'' (Rogues always have money)."

No word on exactly what "bad luck" was afterward discovered relating to the "swindle board." Florizel's final assessment reminds us, once again, why that important--no, vital--hollow box: the "Hesperus" indicator for the Additor, was so important to his acceptance of Schwenke's device even as he totally dismissed all others:

"Such contrivances, where a scientific principle such as the Hesperus Od-Collector is entirely lacking, debase the spiritualistic idea into a farce."

Who knew that a little hollow box was so integral to the operation of an entire class of historical devices? And here I've been collecting these totally bunk spirit communicators for all these years, with nary a one carrying a hollow Od amplifier. I'm so embarrassed. At least Bang Williams got one right.

So, another contrivance to the list then, dear readers!

Florizel von Reuter's "Additor" & "Hesperus"

I'm fortunate to have my pal Marc covering my ass. 

There's no one more passionate about not only the preservation of data, but the sharing of that data than Mr. Demarest, and it is one of my great joys in life to receive snippets and hints from him in my inbox that lead me toward incredibly fruitful chases. No wild geese here--only golden, egg-laying ones. 

The Direct Voice, August, 1930

Marc's endless hunt for obscure esoterica to add to our ever-increasing digital library of occult knowledge brought a couple of exceedingly rare issues of The Direct Voice into his brief possession for digitizing, and the result is another previously-unknown contribution to the world of talking boards. 

I saw the inside cover of the September issue first, and there, in all its glory, was evidence of a new, hitherto unknown artifact: the "Additor," offered by the Direct Voice's publisher, Sunshine Publishing Company, which is most likely the enterprise of Dr. Henry J. Smythe, and not to be confused with the later Sunshine Publishing Company of "Solaire Universelle Nudisme (SUN)"--a magazine for nudists--fame, who's right-to-distribute Supreme Court decision paved the way for High Hefner's Playboy, Larry Flynt's Hustler, and countless other purveyors of pornography and, errrr...articles. 

 

An immediate frustration appeared right there in the September issue: it tantalizingly says, right there, that there's an article "last issue" regarding the device. I frantically switched windows to see what the only other surviving issue sent to me was. August! YES!

Unfortunately, the August issue contains the exact same ad (only in a baby-shit green cover--nice!) with the exact same promise of an article in the preceding issue, so, unless more issues came to light that finally cover the period that von Reuter's article actually does appear (not likely, warned Marc), I was afraid he would have to stay silent on the matter for the time being.

Boy, was I wrong. Turns out Florizel has a LOT to say on the Additor. About 3 novels worth, in fact.

Any readers who are fans of classical music may already know Florizel von Reuter. He was a child prodigy violinist, born in America, raised there as well as in London and Switzerland, and graduated from Europe's venerable and famed music conservatory, the Conservatoire de musique de Genève, at the ripe old age of 11 (though he later claimed 9). He was an acclaimed performer in his day (take a listen), and toured America and Europe extensively in his teenage years and beyond, though his early career was interrupted by the Great War. His talent as a performer and composer was widely recognized, and Sir Conan Doyle said of his concerts in Great Britain: "He appeared unsupported twenty times in the largest halls of London, and he gave eighty-five concerts in the provinces: He also appeared three times in Buckingham Palace before Queen Alexandra and King Edward VII."

Florizel in 1901, aged 11, and an advertisement for a tour stop at Boston's Chickering Hall  the following year.

In June 1925, von Reuter became interested in spirit communication after attending his first séance. By his own account, this interest was sparked with a visit to the San Diego home of Lyman Gage--President McKinley's former Secretary of Treasure--who occasionally hosted séances in his home. Gage was an accomodating host to the famous musician, but apparently much less so to the mediums whom he hired to lead his family's sessions: Florizel reports such fraud-busting tests as Gage filling the palms of the medium's hands with flour, her mouth with purple grape juice, draping her in fishnet, and the requisite arm and leg binding. 

Gage spared Florizel's witness of such controls for his first séance, however, and the attending trumpet medium, Mrs. Stella White, "simply sat on a stool in the middle of the room. with two aluminium trumpets on the floor before her" before producing "spirit-voices," "spirit-lights," "spirit-hands," along with the expected trumpet manifestations and personal revelations of the 10 people assembled.

Von Reuter--his mother's faced obscured by spirits--and a few extra "friends."

Von Reutuer remained somewhat dubious of the produced phenomenon, though was struck with the personal knowledge the medium displayed regarding both he and his mother, particularly when the voice of the spirit of the great violinist Paganini--whose musical heir Florizel was largely thought to be--issued forth from the trumpet in fluent Italian. 

Florizel then began investigations into the psychic sciences, seeking out mediums and clairvoyants wherever he traveled, where he was always impressed with the knowledge the spirits exhibited of him, particularly when he assumed he was incognito, famous violinist though he be. He also posed for numerous spirit photographs with good results. But soon, he returned to Europe and his explorations went briefly dormant.

Florizel's beloved mother and medium, Grace von Reuter.

But while staying at the castle of an anonymous Count in northern Germany, "in the heart of a great pine and beech forest," Florizel and his mother encountered the device that would change his life. He visited the apothecary at the nearby village, and happened upon "herr apotheker" poring over a book on the occult. The two struck up a conversation on topics esoteric, and the pharmacist revealed his "wife had recently became the possessor of a psychical apparatus that gives such remarkable messages that I feel impelled to study the subject."

His wife was soon called in, revealing the device to Florizel. It is described as:

"a board of polished wood about twelve inches long by five wide. Along the upper half of the long side of this board the alphabet was printed, [other passages describe "Ja" and "Nein" as the printed affirmative and negative] in addition to numerals up to ten, and the German phrase, ''Gott zum Gruss '' (Greeting in the name of God). With this simple board went a peculiar little round hollow box with a pointer protruding from it. According to the apothecary, if one put this box, hollow side down, on the lower half of the board, turning the [little black] pointer towards the letters, and then placed the tips of one's fingers on the smooth top, the box would soon begin to move automatically and messages of the most complicated character would be forthcoming. ''Oh, yes," thought I skeptically,''just another kind of ouija-board or planchette.""

If the last sentence is not indication enough, Florizel had no small amount of disdain for the Ouija, and he stated his distaste explicitly: "I have never been interested, even superficially, in the ouija-board. Its little easily moved three-legged table that jumps about over the big board encircling latter after letter has always seemed to me much more likely to be guided unintentionally by the operator than by any spirit force."

That's a burn.

According to his further descriptions (for our sharp-eyed readers to discover, of course, and come running back to me!), the device's instructions were pasted around the outer perimeter of the "hollow box." The indicator is what fascinated von Reuter more than anything. The explanatory text indicated "it had a much
deeper significance than anything connected with the well-known ouija-board, the box being, in fact, an "Od-collector,"" with "Od," of course, referring to Reichenbach's vital life energy later harvested by George Lucas for his Force.

Despite his distaste for the Ouija, Florizel was incredibly smitten by this take on the talking board. The hollow box operated under the same theories as mediums' cabinets, concentrating the Odic force and ectoplasm necessary for spirit manifestation. "This Hesperus idea appealed to me. The fingertips pressing lightly on top of the receiver; the electro-magnetic force flowing into the vacuum of the hollow box; the concentrated force propelling the box: there was something logical, scientific, about this consequential result that gripped my common sense." This indicator had its own name: "Hesperus" (Evening Star), while the board was dubbed the "Additor" (Italian for "indicating with the finger"). The pasted instructions dubbed it the "most authentic bridge between the Earth and the Hereafter," and Florizel immediately sought out the device's inventor.

As it turns out, the inventor, a "poor old scientist," lived in a village just an hour's drive from the castle where Florizel was then residing. His name was Paul Schwenke, and as von Reuter specifically mentions that he had "invented other things and been awarded several gold medals in different countries for his inventions," it is very likely it is the same Schwenke, "a subject of the Duke of Anhalt, residing at Zerbst, in the Dukedom of Anhalt, German Empire" responsible for the 1889 electric lock patent in the US. 

Revealed at last: Florizel transcribes his blindfolded mother's Additor communications, 1926.

Florizel purchased a set of the communication devices and returned to his mother, where they initially obtained few and disappointing results. "It seemed as if our bodies were entirely devoid of the mysterious force from which mediumistic phenomenon emanate, so that we could not charge the little box. We were almost ready to throw the whole apparatus away when suddenly things began to happen." 

Additor detail

Indeed, things certainly happened. With his mother acting as the medium,  the "Hesperus floated from one end of the board to the other, stopping at different letters en route, my mother became conscious of a peculiar impelling force which caused the box to glide and stop, although her fingertips were barely touching it." The communications were varied, and oftentimes came in reverse script, and in various languages. As hurriedly scribbled by Florizel, the very first communique read:

h c i e z t u h c s h c i e n o h
c s h c i e t h c a  b o e b h c i e n r a
w h c i e t a r h c i e h c a w n e b e i
s n e t h c i l f p e b a h h c i...etc, etc

The inverted German would read: "Ich habe pflichten sieben wache ich
rate ich warne ich beobachte ich schone ich schutze ich" or, translated: ''I guard, I protect, I observe, I warn, I advise, I watch. Seven duties have I." Eventually, the board's primary guiding spirit would reveal itself, a formerly "Latin and Catholic" entity called Euphrosyne--the saint, the couple surmised. 

A solicitation for von Reuter's 1931 book of spirit communications: A Musician's Talks with Unseen Friends

Thus began the communications that would not only conjure messages from a who's who of famously dead classical musicians, including Paganini and Pablo de Sarasate, the late Professor Heinrich Barth of Berlin, and Joseph Joachim, among many, many others. In fact, over three novels worth of communications followed, the first published with a foreword by Sir Conan Doyle (with whom Florizel corresponded and visited frequently) as The Psychic Experiences of a Musician (in Search of Truth) in 1928, its shorter predecessor The Hesperus Additor: Planchette Experiences in 1927, its sequel The Consoling Angel following in 1930, and A Musician's Talks with Unseen Friends in 1931, as well as assorted other essays. He also participated in some of Baron von Schrenck-Notzing's investigations of the Austrian mediums, the brothers Rudi and Willi Schneider, in the late 1920s. Eventually, Florizel gave up his psychic investigations and refocused full-time on music, dying after a decade's worth of "farewell" concerts in 1985 after a long and fruitful life.

Investigating the Schneider Brothers at Baron von Schrenck-Notzing's estate. Von Reuter not pictured.

Florizel von Reuter's records of the spirit communications received by his mother and transcribed by him make fascinating reading, if nothing more for the dedication and enthusiasm the pair had for their experiments with the Hesperus and Additor. The writings have become the gift-that-keeps-on-giving for a device researcher such as myself, and include an account of another device previously-unknown device we'll be investigating in an upcoming post.

It's actually kind of funny we didn't know all about this before. While digital editions of von Reuter's work aren't available (God bless the HRC!), there was already ample evidence in the public eye of this board's existence. There's a shot of the device in use on the youtube video posted above, for example, and Florizel's wikipedia page even mentions the Additor and his work with it, for crying out loud. Sometimes, these things are just hiding there, right in front of you, eluding discovery by the right researcher concealed in plain sight.  

As for the Additor and its Hesperus indicator, we know some reached American shores. The Sunshine Publishing Company advertised that they imported "only a few sets" from Germany, if the ad's claims are correct, and likely at the insistence of the Additor's biggest fan and Direct Voice contributor, Florizel himself. No known specimens have appeared, but we do know what to look for, between von Reuter's detailed descriptions and the picture that gives us some indication. Unfortunately, the little village where my research indicates inventor Paul Schwenke lived was flattened by Allied bombs in WWII, so it seems the possibility of finding one at the source is highly unlikely, and it is unknown how popular the device was in its homeland. As always, eyes open, true believers!

A Survey of Automatic Writing (not Written Automatically)

One question that pops up constantly in radio interviews and seminars is why the planchette eventually went the way of the dodo. I am always quick to remind listeners of two realities: the planchette had a long and vibrant career right up through WWII, and the Ouija and other talking boards are just a natural evolution of the device, with more popular appeal. Of course, there's always that curious leapfrog of technology from really-refined-and-darned-near-talking-board-like alphabet card use, not to mention alphabet calling, but from the early 1850s until the late 1880s, automatic writing reigned.

Why is it curious? I thought I'd take a blog post to let the words speak for themselves--literally--and provide some examples of automatic writing for your perusal and interpretation. Some of these are planchette-produced. Others are produced directly from the medium. All are scrawl. So, imagine trying to interpret these significant messages from deceased loved ones in the dimly-lit chamber of a seance room, and wonder if you, too, wouldn't seek a better way, and welcome the more refined talking board once it makes its appearance.

An early automatic writing specimen, from Judge Edmund's Spiritualism, received May 25, 1853.

One of the earliest facsimiles of automatic writing was reproduced in the pages of Judge John Worth Edmund's Spiritualism in 1855. It is a spidery, scrawling script, received by Dr. George T. Dexter acting as medium, which reads: "What is one moment of joy = the joy of the spirit when it realizes the good it has done, to years of this world's pleasure - - I.T.T." Other similar communications, in various handwritings, were received in prior and subsequent seances, from such luminaries as Swedenborg and Bacon among them.

Automatic Mirror-Writing (original, left) from L.A. Sherman's Science of the Soul, 1895.

There are many instances, such as the specimen pictured above, of spirits writing in automatic "mirror-writing." The above example is taken from Loren A. Sherman's Science of the Soul, a book written after the author turned to Spiritualism in the wake of his son's death.  The author received this example from his own father via the anonymous medium "Mr. R.," who also served as the house trumpet medium. When held to a mirror (or reversed in Photoshop), it reads: "You must know it a pleasure to see and commune with you. We are so glad to see you. Rest assured we will assist you and watch over you and yours. Father."  Kate Fox famously had a brief revival of her fading star when she revealed she was capable of mirror-writing in this manner.

Automatic Writing Specimen of W. Stainton Moses, Appleton's Popular Science Monthly, August, 1896.

In some cases, entities channeled through automatic writing attempted to prove claims of their former identities by providing signatures meant to match theirs in life, such as the case with the above example. In this instance, a channeled spirit claiming to be that of William Stainton Moses, channeled through the medium Mr. B______ in the early 1890s, provided the signature, above, that hardly matched his actual signature from life, posted immediately below.

Matching signatures from L.A. Sherman's Science of the Soul, 1895

Although in some cases, as with this specimen again taken from Sherman's Science of the Soul, the matched results of automatic writing signatures to the hand of the recently-deceased would be pretty convincing. Can you imagine a grieving father receiving this kind of proof of life-after-death in the wake of his son's death, or the means he would go through (or money he would pay) to continue the communications. In this case, the seances lasted for years.

Automatic writing specimens from the medium Elizabeth Poole, 1947.

The Hamilton Files website is a rich, fascinating, and exhaustive research into the investigations of its eponymous inspiration, George Hamilton, and specimens there, more than other examples here, show the difficulty in interpreting automatic writing text. This one particularly telling example, from the hand of the medium Mrs. Elizabeth Poole, channeling the spirit of W.T. Stead on April 24, 1927, demonstrates some other technical problems with automatic writing: space and time. That is, one needs ample space to write, particularly when planchettes are involved (though that's not the case here), and, with any lack of space, seance sitters must be quick on the draw to renew the writing surface for the medium before their entranced hand falls off the page. Never mind taking the time to interpret the results in real time: 

In other words, that's an awful lot of work to gather the rather appropriate message: "Why your classroom is too small...you should get...a larger classroom." No mention is made by Mr. Stead, it should be noted, of the sitters acquiring a larger notepad.

Mrs. Poole summons her ectoplasmic guide, Walter, in preparation for automatic writing as given above.

For those that have not yet had the chance to lose hours to the Hamilton Files site, I encourage you to do so. It is an absolute treasure-trove, and this certainly won't be the last time you see examples from that research appearing in the Mysterious Planchette pages.

A message from Sarah Underwood's Automatic or Spirit Writing, 1896. Transcription below.

And, finally, one of my personal favorite specimens of automatic writing, particularly due to the absolute mind-bending complexity of the sentence received, produced by Sarah Underwood in her 1896 book, Automatic or Spirit Writing, after she posed the question: What should, in your opinion, be our most reasonable attitude toward the existing religious systems of to-day? The written answer reads:

The attitude of convicted believers in spiritual life toward the blind leaders of the blindly dogmatic in spiritual matters should be that of the Seers to those yet in the dark—as full of lovingness and tenderness as one who sees to those bereft of sight, eager to remove the disability but patient with their natural mistakes and halting steps. Remember as they are, so once were ye, and they too shall be ultimately led to the light.

Does the spirit move you? Grab a pen  (the Waterman company recommends the model above) and see what they have to say!